FairSoleSorel or Columbia? Caribou vs Bugaboot snow boots compared
Nesim Yılmaz · 20.10.2026
For proper snow and cold, many people choose one of these two: the classic Sorel Caribou or the Columbia Bugaboot. Both are waterproof and warm – but they feel very different day to day.
At a glance
| Sorel Caribou | Columbia Bugaboot Celsius Plus | |
|---|---|---|
| Build | rubber shell + leather, removable 9 mm felt liner | waterproof boot with built-in insulation |
| Shaft height | tall, approx. 23 cm | lower, approx. 18 cm |
| Weight | heavy | noticeably lighter |
| Brand cold rating | down to −40 °C | varies by model |
| Strength | very warm standing still, classic look | lighter, sportier, better for walking |
Warmth
With its thick felt liner the Caribou is very warm when you're standing around – clearing snow, waiting for a bus, at a Christmas market. The "−40" rating is the brand's own figure with no standard test behind it, and reviewers think it's optimistic. A bonus: you can take the liner out and dry it overnight.
Walking and everyday use
The Caribou is heavy and a bit clunky – fine for short trips, less so for long walks. It also runs large; many people go half a size down. The Bugaboot is lighter and more agile, better if you walk a lot in winter.
UK note
Most British winters are wet rather than deeply frozen. If you rarely see real snow, a waterproof walking boot with good grip may serve you better than either – see our winter boots guide.
Our verdict
- Very cold winters, lots of standing, classic look: Sorel Caribou.
- Lots of walking, town and light trails, less weight: Columbia Bugaboot.
Money-saving tip
Snow boots are cheapest in the January sales – but popular sizes go fast. To be sure of your size, buy around Black Friday.
Matching models on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. The price you pay is the same.